top of page
Search

Are You Giving Your People Answers — Or Helping Them Find Their Own?

Writer: Tim Bishop
Tim Bishop
Nov 9
4 min read

I've always believed that one of the greatest opportunities in business is helping people recognise just how capable they can become.


Throughout my career, I've worked with people who have demonstrated remarkable ability, judgement and commitment, often exceeding their own expectations when given the opportunity.


But I've also seen situations where capable people have become unnecessarily dependent upon their managers, not because they lacked ability, but because they had become accustomed to somebody else providing the answers.


It's an interesting challenge for anyone in a leadership position, particularly when experience has taught us how to recognise problems and find solutions quickly.


After all, when somebody comes to us with a question, isn't it our responsibility to help them?

Of course it is, but perhaps we should occasionally consider whether the most helpful response is always to provide the answer.


The Temptation to Solve Everything


When you've spent years developing your experience, solving problems can become almost instinctive. You recognise a situation, understand the likely consequences and can often identify a sensible course of action before the person explaining the problem has finished speaking.


There's real value in that experience, particularly when a decision is urgent or the consequences of getting something wrong could be significant.


But not every situation requires an immediate solution from the most experienced person in the room.


Sometimes, our enthusiasm to help means we step in too quickly. We provide the answer, explain what needs to happen and move on to the next challenge, satisfied that we've been useful.


And we probably have been useful, at least in the short term.


However, there's another question worth considering: What has the other person learned from that exchange?


They may now know what to do, but have they developed a better understanding of how to approach a similar situation in the future?


If the answer is no, we may find ourselves having much the same conversation again.


Confidence Develops Through Experience


I think most of us can remember somebody who helped us develop professionally. Perhaps it was a manager, colleague or mentor who recognised something in us that we hadn't yet recognised in ourselves.


Often, those people didn't simply tell us what to do. They encouraged us to think, challenged our assumptions and gave us the confidence to make decisions.


Sometimes they allowed us to make mistakes, provided the consequences were manageable and there was something valuable to learn.


That experience matters because confidence doesn't develop simply through being told that we're capable. It develops when we're given opportunities to demonstrate that capability,

and this is where leadership becomes particularly important.


If we want people to take greater responsibility, exercise sound judgement and contribute more meaningfully to the organisation, we need to create opportunities for them to do so.


That doesn't mean leaving people unsupported or expecting them to know things they haven't yet been taught. It means recognising the difference between providing guidance and removing the need for somebody to think.


Sometimes a Question Is More Valuable Than an Answer


One of the simplest changes a leader can make is to become a little more curious before offering a solution.


When somebody brings you a problem, rather than immediately explaining what you would do, you might ask:


“What do you think we should do?”


Or perhaps, “What options have you considered?” and “What do you think might happen if we approached it that way?”


These aren't complicated questions, but they can change the nature of the conversation.

Instead of one person providing instructions and another following them, both become involved in exploring the situation.


The leader still contributes their experience, but the other person has an opportunity to develop their own understanding and judgement.


Of course, there will always be circumstances where clear direction is necessary. Good leadership involves recognising when to guide, when to decide and when to give somebody the space to find their own way forward.


The objective isn't to stop providing answers. It's to avoid becoming the only person who can provide them.


Developing People Strengthens the Business


There's also a wider organisational benefit to this approach.


When people feel trusted to think, contribute and make appropriate decisions, they often become more confident and engaged in their work. Their understanding of the business improves, and they begin to recognise opportunities or potential problems without always waiting for somebody else to point them out.


Over time, that creates an organisation with greater capability at every level.


It also creates more capacity for the business owner or leader.


Instead of continually resolving the same operational questions, they can devote more attention to developing the organisation, supporting its people and considering what needs to happen next.


This is one of the reasons I place so much importance on sharing experience.


Experience only has value when it is shared.


But sharing experience doesn't always mean telling somebody what you've learned. Sometimes it means using that experience to help another person develop their own.


What Is Your Leadership Encouraging?


Perhaps the most useful question isn't whether your people come to you for advice. In a healthy organisation, they should feel comfortable doing so.


The more interesting question is what happens as a result.


Do those conversations leave people feeling more confident and capable, or simply reassured that you'll provide the answer next time?


Are you creating an environment where people are encouraged to think, contribute and take responsibility, or one where they wait for direction?


I don't believe leadership is measured by how many questions we can answer. I think it's better reflected in the confidence, judgement and capability we help develop in others.

Because the real opportunity isn't to become indispensable to every decision.


It's to build a business where more people have the confidence and ability to make good decisions themselves.


And perhaps that's worth reflecting on the next time somebody comes to you with a problem.


Before you give them the answer, could you help them find their own?

 

 
 
bottom of page